The Basic Question Every Investor Faces
How much in stocks, how much in bonds, how much in gold? The split across asset classes, known as asset allocation, is one of the most important decisions in any investment strategy. For more than 70 years, the standard approach has been one that goes back to Nobel laureate Harry Markowitz. It requires two steps: First, you estimate the returns and volatility to expect from each asset class and how the assets influence one another. From this, the optimal mix is then calculated. The weakness lies in the first step. Future returns can only be estimated imprecisely, and even small estimation errors can lead to heavily distorted portfolios, without this being apparent at first glance.
The Idea: Learning Directly from Experience
The research team—Dr. Simon Broda (Institute of Financial Services Zug IFZ at the Lucerne University of Applied Sciences and Arts), Prof. Dr. Gianluca De Nard (University of Liechtenstein and University of Zurich), and Dr. Patrick Walker (OLZ AG and University of Zurich)—took a different path. Their model is a simple approach from reinforcement learning. Here, a computer program does not learn from predefined solutions but from the outcomes of its own decisions: It tries out allocations on historical data, receives feedback on how well they balanced return and risk, and adjusts its behavior step by step.
The difference from the classical approach can be illustrated with a simple question. The classical approach asks: What return will gold deliver next year? The new model asks: When interest rates are rising and markets are jittery, which mix has proven itself in such conditions? The error-prone detour through forecasting is eliminated.
The model is based on the price performance and risk characteristics of the asset classes as well as economic indicators such as interest rates, inflation, unemployment, or market volatility. From these, it derives a new allocation once a month. The study examined six broad, predominantly U.S. asset classes, all of which can be replicated inexpensively through exchange-traded funds (ETFs): stocks, gold, listed real estate, commodities, government bonds, and corporate bonds (Figure 1).
Why a Simple Approach Is Enough
Reinforcement learning became famous through programs that master chess or Go. Such systems are complex because every move changes the rest of the game. Financial markets are different: An investor whose trading volume is small relative to the market does not influence prices. Today’s decision therefore does not change tomorrow’s starting position. The researchers take advantage of this and treat each month as an independent decision. As a result, the model gets by without the elaborate machinery of typical reinforcement learning systems and can be trained in a lean and fast manner.
A second trick comes on top of that: The model does not start from scratch but begins with the classical Markowitz solution and tries to improve on it step by step using the data.